Liquid Barcodes


Loyalty Learnings from China

Paula Thomas, Chief Content Officer, Liquid Barcodes


This article first appeared on Global Convenience Store Focus.

China as a nation was once primarily known as a country simply producing cheap imitation and counterfeit products in an attempt to mimic the prosperity of western economies. But in less than a decade it has transformed its approach, becoming a global technology leader and the number one nation in the world in terms of investment in digital technologies. The results have been nothing short of sensational, catapulting China to become the second most valuable nation brand in the world, with Chinese companies now making up 50 of the Global 500 most valuable brands.

Their approach has transformed every aspect of life in China, so we wanted to understand how they have leveraged their extra-ordinary digital eco-system to drive consumer loyalty, and uncover what ideas are working with Chinese consumers that we can learn from and share with you. We particularly wanted to understand the impact of this digital-first economy on the convenience industry and whether Chinese eCommerce giants are threatening the need for convenience stores in everyday life.

Is eCommerce Killing Convenience?

The short answer is a resounding no. In fact, the industry was recently described by visiting Harvard Business School Professor Mr. Ananth Raman as enjoying unprecedented vitality.

We know that Jack Ma the founder of the Alibaba Group has repeatedly introduced the idea of “new retail” which blurs the lines between online and offline, however we’ve also witnessed internet-style companies like Luckin’ Coffee disrupting brands like Starbucks and enticing consumers to choose to have their coffee delivered instead of collecting it from their local store. It’s a radical behaviour change but seems to be growing the overall sector (rather than diluting it) by making coffee easier to enjoy for busy Chinese millennials.

In fact, according to this years China Convenience Development Report by KPMG, convenience stores are actually becoming increasingly popular, with compound annual growth rate of 20%, and now over 120,000 stores. The report details nine key insights and trends being seen with Chinese convenience retailers, including the “active promotion of digital transformation and loyalty programmes”. As discussed below, it includes some interesting case studies and trends driving loyalty in China, some of which we believe will become popular in other global markets.

KPMG Reports

KPMG Reports Continued Growth in the Convenience Retail Sector in China

Top Three Trends in Loyalty in China

2017 loyalty research conducted by Mastercard in the Asia Pacific region reported an “unquestionable appetite for loyalty among the burgeoning middle classes” in emerging markets such as China, India and Indonesia, with an average membership of 7.6 loyalty programmes in these markets.

It’s impossible to capture the trends, ideas and insights for this vast region in one article, so today we are focusing on the top three loyalty trends we’re seeing in China. Some are successful strategies that originated in more mature markets, however there are interesting lessons on how Western strategies have been adapted for Chinese consumers, and it will be fascinating to see if any of these Eastern ideas are in the future picked up back in Western mature markets.

  1. Paid Subscription Programmes (with tiers!)

When Alibaba, the Chinese eCommerce giant launched its loyalty programme called “88” (which means “double fortune“) in August 2017, there were more contrasts than similarities with the Amazon Prime loyalty programme. Primarily, Amazon Prime charges a simple $99 annual membership fee and offers consistent benefits, led by unlimited fast, free, delivery services. By contrast, Alibaba customers joined for free but earned points and a score, called Taoqizhi, for their shopping and social behaviour and were then categorised in to clear groups – 88 Members, Super 88 Members and Selected 88 Members. The benefits were clearly segmented and became increasingly valuable and emphasised a strategy to move “beyond growth to experiences”.

Yet one year after launch, Alibaba introduced an additional tier as a paid option, inviting members to upgrade and become an “88 VIP” member, and the price point to access the huge range of benefits was ten times more expensive for customers with fewer than 1,000 points at RMB888 ($129.77) but just RMB88 ($12.86) for those with 1,000 membership points. The full press release announcing the launch of the paid subscription programme and its benefits can be read here. No results have yet been published on how many members have paid to join, however there’s no doubt that the scale of Alibaba has created extra-ordinary incentives for millions of members to do exactly that.

Another aspect of this programme that’s critically important to notice is their loyalty brand’s strategy which will be of interest to other brands interested in this market. It is the use of “lucky numbers’ – 8 in particular – whether in branding or even pricing as seen above. This approach is used to a much lesser extent  in Western countries (eg mainly in pricing such as the use of .99 cents) however as a branding tool, it’s critical in Eastern cultures.

Paid Subscription Model

Alibaba Launch a Paid Subscription Model in 2018.

2. Loyalty Beyond Purchases

What’s incredibly interesting in the Alibaba strategy – and a strategy that I believe will become increasingly important in global loyalty programmes – is the focus on connecting and contributing to the community. Alibaba has realised the importance of encouraging members to share products on social media, post questions in community forums or write product reviews useful to other consumers and so they earn both points and privileges beyond simply their purchases, behaviours that increase the value of the overall platform to other members of the community and therefore the overall stickiness of the programme.

Jiang Fan is the lead for the loyalty initiative, and he says, “We care about how consumers feel on the platform. We want to bring them more than just goods, but also a better lifestyle.”

This is a fascinating focus on members who are “engaged, credible and consistently active”, providing better experiences and a virtuous circle of valuable connections for “the largest consumer community in the world”.

consumer community

3. Dominant Digital Ecosystem

No article about loyalty programmes or digital trends in China would be complete without discussing Wechat – the platform originally launched just eight years ago as a messaging platform. It has since grown to over a billion monthly users and as the video below shows, it has become the single essential platform for brands and consumers to connect.

Its ecosystem has been labelled a “superapp” as its features includes extensive access to Chinese services, with recent research by China Channel quoting that almost half of customers no longer even carry cash.

Whether its to connect loyal customers with brands for marketing, payments, customer service, coupons or simply gifting between family and friends, Wechat has become the default platform to find, support and keep customers, and one we’ll continue to write about in our ongoing articles about digital loyalty platforms and programmes. 

The New York Times Explains the Dominance of WeChat for Chinese Consumers

Global Lessons in Loyalty

No matter what part of the world you are based, there’s no doubt that China is enjoying both the necessary scale and ambition to offer us great ideas and insights as to what truly matters to customers. As one article said so well: “China is no longer simply the factory to the world. It is the world’s fastest-growing consumer market”, so while cultural variations are inevitable, our belief is that human beings are more alike than different, which will ensure that China will continue to give us unique insights and ideas how to drive loyalty with our customers worldwide.


“Loyalty” in simplified Chinese. 

About Us:

Liquid Barcodes is a leading global loyalty and digital marketing technology company specialised for the convenience store and foodservice industries. Our proprietary cloud-based technology platform allow retailers to create and manage their digital marketing campaigns with a proprietary process we call the “customer connection cycle’ to engage, promote and reward customers activities in real-time across digital and media channels.

How we do it:

We have developed the most advanced loyalty and digital marketing technology platform specifically for convenience store and foodservice retailers globally.

Retailers use our self-service dashboard to create and manage loyalty driven marketing campaigns that increase purchases with their existing customers, as well as effectively target and acquire new customers through partners or paid media channels.

One core component of live loyalty is gamification. We have gamified branding, loyalty and promotions. We believe this approach is essential in order to get customers’ attention and ultimately truly engage them with repeatable actions thereby winning their loyalty.

Check out some of our exciting/proven results here:

About Me:

Paula Thomas

Chief Content Officer, Liquid Barcodes and Independent Loyalty Consultant.

With over twenty-five years marketing experience, I specialise in loyalty marketing consulting, managing consumer loyalty propositions, strategy and operations. In addition to working with Liquid Barcodes, my clients have included Telefonica O2, Three Mobile, Electric Ireland, Allied Irish Bank and The Entertainer, as well as Avios – the global points currency for some of the world’s top airlines. I am also a judge for the Loyalty Magazine Awards. 


Blog post

5 Cs of Summer: Cold Coffee, Clean Cars & Convenience

Subscription programs are a great way to secure long-term customer loyalty and revenue. Whether you are providing a subscription for beverages or car washes, securing recurring monthly revenue is imperative to stay competitive.   Summer is around the corner and retail marketers are crafting sunny campaigns to increase customer traffic to the store. Help those […]

Blog post

Circle K Makes a Splash With Car Wash Subscription Program in Europe

Circle K has extended its highly successful car wash subscription program to Norway after successful implementations in the United States, Canada, Denmark, Sweden and Estonia. Circle K’s vast global network of car washes has digitally transformed operations with its revolutionary car wash subscription program. First launched in Denmark and the U.S. in 2020, the program […]

Blog post

Newly Redesigned Brezelkönig App Accepts Payments and Rewards Loyalty

Swiss foodservice chain Brezelkönig releases app update which offers customers the convenience of earning rewards and paying for products with the app in stores.  The recently-updated Brezelkönig app allows pretzel-loving customers to enjoy recognition and rewards for their loyalty. Additionally, the Brezelkönig app accepts payments to make the customer experience even more convenient.  Brezelkönig is […]

Blog post

Sunshine Gasoline Introduces ACH-Only Mobile Payment for Fuel

Florida convenience retailer releases fuel payment app accepting only ACH payment, saving thousands in payment processing fees for the retailer. Sunshine Gasoline upgraded its Max Carwash App to Sunshine Brand featuring a special fuel pay program, powered by C-StorePay by Liquid Barcodes, which allows consumers to conveniently pay for fuel using the app. Customers simply […]

Blog post

2022: An Outstanding Year for Liquid Barcodes and Our Customers

In 2022, Liquid Barcodes witnessed a year of unprecedented growth with customers, products and team members. Every great business has an inspiring founding story and Liquid Barcodes’ 10-year journey is inspiring the future of loyalty. Beginning as a startup in Norway, the company opened its second office in the United States in early 2022 and […]

Blog post

What Is C-StorePay?

Liquid Barcodes’ proprietary C-StorePay makes paying for fuel, in-store merchandise, and subscription programs convenient for customers, reduces credit card fees for retailers, and integrates easily into existing loyalty programs Announced in October 2022, the revolutionary Liquid Barcodes C-StorePay product rose to the top of retailers’ 2022 wish lists at the NACS Show, even achieving a […]

Blog post

Polish Retail Leader Żabka Launches Coffee Subscription Program

Polish retail giant, Żabka introduces a monthly coffee subscription program across its vast store network. With its new coffee subscription program, Żabka Polska will certainly dominate the beverage category in Poland’s unique convenience market. In July 2022, Dr. Adam Manikowski, Managing Director of Żabka Polska, was featured on the popular Global Convenience Store Focus video […]

Blog post

Loyalty Apps Engage Customers

98% of loyalty app users love using a loyalty app and want more features from it. In September 2022, NACS published a report examining customer engagement with convenience loyalty programs. Unsurprisingly, customers feel most engaged, appreciated and valued by the stores to which they belong in a loyalty or membership program – nearly ¾ of […]

Blog post

Save Thousands in Credit Card Fees With ACH

Visa and Mastercard announced an increase in interchange fees earlier in the year and retailers are taking action and sending a message by migrating their customers to new solutions, including mobile app-based ACH payments, and in the process increasing profits by not only reducing credit card fees but also boosting loyalty via innovative app-based incentive […]

Blog post

Maxol Launches First-of-Its-Kind Loyalty App

Maxol, Ireland’s largest family-owned forecourt and convenience retailer, announced it has launched a new customer loyalty app with never-before-seen features in the Irish market. After more than a century serving Irish customers, Maxol’s 240+ stores and service stations are located throughout Ireland and have enjoyed global recognition for their best-in-class operations, store design and offers. […]

Blog post

Delivering Personalized Content With Machine Learning and Image Recognition

Build personalized customer connections, improve efficiency, and make intelligent, data-driven decisions using machine learning and image recognition.   It’s 7:15 in the morning and a customer – Amy – is on her way to work. She is on the hunt for coffee and breakfast and stops at a convenience store. She opens her store app […]

Blog post

Circle K’s Use of Beacon Technology to Activate Car Wash Subscription Program

Beacon Technology and Car Wash Subscription Programs Beacon technology used in tandem with a customer-facing car wash subscription program revolutionizes the customer experience by providing a quick, convenient experience. Innovation is the key to continued growth and ensuring a frictionless customer experience should be top of mind for any retailer. Circle K’s vast global network […]

Liquid Barcodes

Put a rocket under your loyalty program

With our loyalty platform, we help design and operate world-class, tailor-made subscription and reward programs that make sure your customers always come back.

Book a Demo →

We are trusted by global brands.

Convenience retailers all over the world have engaged and rewarded consumers with our tailor-made loyalty programs.

To our case studies →

Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes

Convenience retailers all over the world have engaged and rewarded consumers with our tailor-made loyalty programs.

To our case studies →

Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes