Liquid Barcodes


Plus or Prime?

Paula Thomas, Chief Content Officer, Liquid Barcodes


The release of Walmart+ last month has given US consumers plenty to think about. In fact, it’s extra-ordinary that Walmart+ is seen as a key competitor to Amazon Prime a full fifteen years after the Amazon concept was launched, and even despite the existence of a previous Walmart program known as “Delivery Unlimited”.

While “delivery unlimited” ONLY offered free unlimited delivery, Walmart+ promises “lots of other benefits”, so our professional curiosity was of course piqued. In this article, we are sharing our views on this latest industry launch.

Walmart+Walmart+ launched September 2020 – fifteen years after Amazon Prime

US Online Grocery Giants Compete

At first glance, Amazon Prime and Walmart+ offer incredibly similar benefits, yet as usual, the devil is in the detail. The table below illustrates just how similar the two brands are in terms of their online grocery services. At a slightly cheaper annual fee, Walmart+ appears cheaper, however the minimum spend requirement may mean it’s not always as useful for customers as the Prime option.

From a purely grocery perspective, with almost 5,000 Walmart stores across the country, Walmart are calling their new program “the ultimate life hack” and suggesting that the sheer scale of their retail footprint combined with this option for unlimited deliveries offers “unprecedented value”, claiming to save customers “time and money like no other retailer can.” It’s certainly a big statement given the fifteen year time lag mentioned earlier.

Comparison Table Courtesy of USA TodayComparison Table Courtesy of USA Today

For us, the $21 price difference is probably the least important criteria to choose between the two giants, particularly as the core proposition of Walmart+ is simply a re-brand of “delivery unlimited”. Many of the US’s top media such as USA Today have discussed the two current grocery options in great detail, comparing delivery times, brand availability and value of money, so we will focus on the other key factors that may tip the scales in Walmart’s favour. We have previously discussed Amazon’s key selling points in our article – Prime’s Proven Power, with Jeff Bezos describing it as “so good, customers would be irresponsible not to join”.

USP #1:

With so much focus on driving savings on grocery spend, it seems hard to predict whether Amazon or Walmart can consistently offer the most savings on grocery purchases alone. Therefore, the first selling point that Walmart+ can claim as a unique benefit for their members is the added savings on gas. Walmart+ members save up to 5 cents a gallon at nearly 2,000 Walmart, Murphy USA and Murphy Express fuel stations, similar to loyalty subscription propositions we’ve written about from both Racetrac Rewards and 7Eleven stores in certain states. It seems unlikely (but certainly not impossible) that Amazon Prime will choose to compete with this service offering any time soon. Therefore, for consumers who drive a lot and are keen to save on fuel, Walmart+ will win out.

USP #2:

It’s impossible to predict when (or if) consumers will shop in supermarkets in the same numbers as before, when they do, the “Scan & Go” option for Walmart+ members will undoubtedly prove to be a faster way to shop. As you can see in the video below, using the app, customers scan their items as they add them to their basket, keep a track of their spend in real time and then pay on their phone using Walmart Pay for a quick, easy and contactless check-out experience.

Bringing digital benefits to physical stores – Walmart+ includes “scan and go” functionality for members.

Is Two Too Many?

As a non US resident, many thousands of miles away from the market these two giants compete in, my conclusion is I would enjoy the benefits of both options at different times. My fuel savings would need to be carefully estimated, but alongside the likelihood I would be shopping in their stores too, I would expect to buy enough from Walmart to justify investing in their Plus membership.

Similarly, Amazon Prime is consistently compelling. Beyond any grocery shopping, the Prime fee is justifiable given the sheer volume of products I buy from them year round – from books to electronics, as well as the extensive Prime Video entertainment library.

Membership Messaging

A final difference is noteworthy between the approach that Walmart is taking compared to Amazon’s transactional & functional approach.

With the loyalty industry highlighting the increasing importance of driving emotional loyalty, it’s great to see Walmart leading its communications strategy for Walmart+ around the idea that we are all first and foremost members of families and communities, and that membership of a program like Plus allows us enjoy those connections even more.

Very nice positioning Walmart! We’ll watch the growth of Walmart+ with great interest.

Walmart+ is positioning its program membership as a way to save time for family and other priorities.

Walmart+ logo

About Us:

Liquid Barcodes is a leading global loyalty and digital marketing technology company specialising in the convenience store and foodservice industries. Our proprietary cloud-based technology platform allow retailers to create and manage their digital marketing campaigns with a proprietary process we call the “customer connection cycle’ to engage, promote and reward customers activities in real-time across digital and media channels.

How we do it:

We have developed the most advanced loyalty and digital marketing technology platform specifically for convenience store and foodservice retailers globally.

Retailers use our self-service dashboard to create and manage loyalty driven marketing campaigns that increase purchases with their existing customers, as well as effectively target and acquire new customers through partners or paid media channels.

One core component of live loyalty is gamification. We have gamified branding, loyalty and promotions. We believe this approach is essential in order to get customers’ attention and ultimately truly engage them with repeatable actions thereby winning their loyalty.

Check out some of our exciting/proven results here:

About Me:

Paula Thomas

Chief Content Officer, Liquid Barcodes and Independent Loyalty Consultant

With over twenty-five years marketing experience, I specialise in loyalty marketing consulting, managing consumer loyalty propositions, strategy and operations. In addition to working with Liquid Barcodes, my clients have included Telefonica O2 Priority, Three Mobile, Electric Ireland, Allied Irish Bank and The Entertainer Group (UAE), as well as Avios – the global points currency for some of the world’s top airlines. I am also a former judge for the Loyalty Magazine Awards and host of the “Let’s Talk Loyalty” podcast.


Blog post

Liquid Barcodes Makes U.S. Debut at 2022 NACS Show

Liquid Barcodes exhibited at the 2022 NACS Show demonstrating loyalty, subscription and payment applications.   For the first time in history, Liquid Barcodes had the pleasure of exhibiting in two prominent locations at the 2022 NACS Show both in the busy New Exhibitor Area as well as in the featured partner kiosk in Verifone’s booth […]

Blog post

Save Thousands in Credit Card Fees With ACH

Visa and Mastercard announced an increase in interchange fees earlier in the year and retailers are taking action and sending a message by migrating their customers to new solutions, including mobile app-based ACH payments, and in the process increasing profits by not only reducing credit card fees but also boosting loyalty via innovative app-based incentive […]

Blog post

Subscription Programs Are Economically Smart Investments

Monthly subscriptions to products and services are economically smart investments for retailers and customers With a recession looming and gas prices still at record-high levels, customers are tightening their grip on their wallets. But this doesn’t mean they’ll be turning their backs on convenience store purchases and there are ways you can weather the impending […]

Blog post

Converting Impulse Shoppers to Automatic Customers

Subscription programs for drinks and snacks encourage customers to change from impulse buyers to automatic customers   Customers stop at gas stations and convenience stores to buy fuel, for beverages and snacks and to use the bathroom, essentially in that order of priority. A NACS survey of gas-buying customers found that half went into the […]

Blog post

Maxol Launches First-of-Its-Kind Loyalty App

Maxol, Ireland’s largest family-owned forecourt and convenience retailer, announced it has launched a new customer loyalty app with never-before-seen features in the Irish market. After more than a century serving Irish customers, Maxol’s 240+ stores and service stations are located throughout Ireland and have enjoyed global recognition for their best-in-class operations, store design and offers. […]

Blog post

Delivering Personalized Content With Machine Learning and Image Recognition

Build personalized customer connections, improve efficiency, and make intelligent, data-driven decisions using machine learning and image recognition.   It’s 7:15 in the morning and a customer – Amy – is on her way to work. She is on the hunt for coffee and breakfast and stops at a convenience store. She opens her store app […]

Blog post

Sweet Tea and Coffee Subscription Beverage Programs Brew Recurring Revenue

As summer nears, consumers are turning their attention towards refreshing iced beverages and iced tea is a hot seller this time of year, especially when sold with a subscription beverage program. Sweet tea might be the quintessential drink of southerners in the U.S, but the rest of the country has developed a taste for the […]

Blog post

Circle K’s Use of Beacon Technology to Activate Car Wash Subscription Program

Beacon Technology and Car Wash Subscription Programs Beacon technology used in tandem with a customer-facing car wash subscription program revolutionizes the customer experience by providing a quick, convenient experience. Innovation is the key to continued growth and ensuring a frictionless customer experience should be top of mind for any retailer. Circle K’s vast global network […]

Blog post

Unlimited Car Washes!

Subscription programs for car washes are a hot trend in convenience retail.

Blog post

Car Wash Program Drives Sales for United Pacific

Car wash programs are revenue drivers for convenience stores and fueling stations around the globe. Making sure the process is convenient and cost-effective for customers increases traffic and drives in-store sales. Oftentimes, car wash units occupy a small corner of the lot and do not receive much attention. This is not the case for those […]

Blog post

Danish Railway Rewards Riders with DSB Plus

The Danish railway system, known as DSB, is going the distance to reward customers by partnering with convenience retailer 7-Eleven to deliver points towards food and coffee simply for riding the rails. Whether commuting or travelling longer distances, riders who join DSB Plus earn points whenever they travel within Denmark. DSB is an abbreviation for […]

Blog post

Subscriptions for the win!

Amazon Prime is, by nature, a subscription under the auspice of membership. Pay an annual fee, get 2-day shipping and exclusive deals. Amazon took it one level further with “Subscribe & Save” where you can get everyday – and not so everyday – items shipped to you on a regular schedule.  In the early days […]

Blog post

Customer Retention Program of Circle K Vietnam

As the first international convenience store brand to launch in Vietnam, Circle K has over a decade of expertise catering to the needs of the 96 million residents of this huge country, operating a network of over four hundred convenience stores each open 24 hours a day! So launching an outstanding customer retention program was […]

Blog post

Stinker Stores Named Best New Loyalty Program in the U.S.

        2021 Best New Loyalty Program  Stinker Stores’ new loyalty program offers multiple redemptions with a single scan and stands out with a gamification feature to keep customers engaged. This article is originally published on CStoreDecisions and written by Erin Del Conte | October 28, 2021 Stinker Stores, with 103 convenience stores across Idaho, […]

Liquid Barcodes

Put a rocket under your loyalty program

With our loyalty platform, we help design and operate world-class, tailor-made subscription and reward programs that make sure your customers always come back.

Book a Demo →

We are trusted by global brands.

Convenience retailers all over the world have engaged and rewarded consumers with our tailor-made loyalty programs.

To our case studies →

Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes

Convenience retailers all over the world have engaged and rewarded consumers with our tailor-made loyalty programs.

To our case studies →

Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes
Liquid Barcodes